Jason, who shares daughters Wyatt, 4, Elliotte, 3, and Bennett, 16 months, with wife Kylie Kelce attended Swift’s Eras Tour concerts on June 21 and June 22

Jason Kelce. PHOTO: NEW HEIGHTS/YOUTUBE

Jason Kelce brought home a special gift from Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour for his oldest daughter Wyatt.

The retired NFL player, 36, revealed on the latest episode of his New Heights podcast with brother Travis Kelce that he made sure to record Swift playing the 4-year-old’s favorite song.

“It’s banger after banger,” Jason said of the concert. “ ‘The Man,’ Wyatt’s favorite song was the second song. Recorded that, sent it over to Wyatt.”

The retired NFL player, who shares daughters Wyatt, Elliotte, 3, and Bennett, 16 months, with wife Kylie Kelce, 32, previously shared that Wyatt also loves Swift’s song “Shake It Off” on an April episode of their podcast.

Wyatt Kelce (left); Jason Kelce.KYLIE KELCE/INSTAGRAM, MITCHELL LEFF/GETTY

Jason Kelce’s 3 Kids: All About His Daughters Wyatt, Elliotte and Bennett

However, while his daughter may love the more upbeat songs from the Grammy-winner’s discography, the former football player shared in the latest podcast episode that the acoustic portion of Swift’s show, where she sings surprise songs from her different albums, was his “favorite part.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

“First of all, I just love acoustic,” Jason said. “When it’s just the musician — it’s just her, a guitar, and 90,000 people… And she’s blending from one song to another and going through it [with the piano…].”

“To be good in front of 90,000 people with just that, I think you have to be amazing,” he explained. “You have to, one, have great songs and great lyrics, which she obviously has written and made. And then two, be able to perform those seamlessly on the spot, nothing else to hide it … that was the highlight of the evening for me.”

At the June 21 concert, which Jason attended, Swift sang her first live performance of “The Black Dog” off her new album The Tortured Poets Department and a mashup of Midnights’ “Hits Different” and Lover’s “Death by a Thousand Cuts.”

Jason Kelce Says Daughter Wyatt Is ‘Doing Great’ in Preschool: ‘Teachers Have Nothing but Rave Reviews’

Travis, 34, chimed in that the acoustic segment is the part of the show “everybody” in the audience is “waiting for.”

“It gets everybody [back] on their seat,” he noted. “And then on top of that, it puts everybody in a room with Taylor.”

“Dude, you’re 90,000 people, but for some reason, it feels like you’re in a bar just listening to somebody play on a piano,” Jason added.